Saturday, July 12, 2014

Andrei Lankov. The Real North Korea. Life and Politics in the Failed Stalinist State.

A. Lankov is a Russian-born professor at South Korea's Kookmin U. I cannot, obviously, judge how accurate his book is but it is a breath of fresh air among neocon-dominated country studies in the US. Current Anglo-American political scientists mostly carry a few pre-set theses on the situation in any country, which they support with cherry-picked "evidence." (E.g. see my review of Richard Sakwa's Putin--and this is not the worst example; on the contrary among the best). Furthermore, neocon-informed country studies take their anthropomorphism of international politics--as if countries were characters in the Greek tragedy with no domestic politics and immutable characters--to an unbearable degree. Measured and well-researched (again, unlike neocon "experts" he has a working knowledge of the language of country he writes about), his book is a welcome addition. In particular, he discusses, at length, why despite official slogans of Korea's unification both  North Korean and South Korean elites are comfortable with the situation as it is.

1 comment:

Alex Bliokh (A. S. Bliokh) said...

Again, unlike Anglo-American international studies, Lankov uses comparative analysis rather than pseudo-historical analogies beloved by the neocons: "Among other things it produced a sad paradox--countries where Communist apparatchiks fared worst... were usually the very same countries where Communism itself was least repressive (Hungary, Poland and Czechoslovakia)." Nobody, vying for the tenure in American university system would dare to compare "advanced" and "model Westerners" Czechs to unwashed barbarians from distant corners of Asia.